Damaged item, does eBay cancel my negative seller feedback?
Summary: burgerquizz shares their frustrating experience with eBay, where after receiving a damaged item and trying to resolve the dispute through PayPal, the seller stopped responding after burgerquizz canceled the dispute. They then left a negative review without defamation, which was removed by eBay, leaving burgerquizz with no refund and no way to warn other buyers. max2661953 advises never to close a dispute before receiving a refund. burgerquizz expresses their disappointment with eBay and their new distrust after this experience.
Having received a damaged item, I opened a PayPal dispute.
Naive, I agreed to close it when the seller proposed a replacement if I canceled the dispute.
Once that was done, the seller no longer replied.
PayPal and eBay can't help me, I file a claim, and leave negative feedback for the seller, without insults or defamation. But the feedback is removed, and on the phone, I'm told it must have been judged defamatory. I ask how, I reread the seller's feedback, who has received 20 negative ones in a year, and I don't understand. I won't be refunded, I can't share the experience with other buyers, and eBay seems to wash its hands of it.
After more than 20 years on the platform and 100% positive feedback on my side, I feel really cheated.
burgerquizz
OPOf course, and from now on, I’ll be less naive.
However, canceling a review is ridiculous (the messages from both parties being easily viewable by Ebay, and showing who ripped off whom)
max2661953
@burgerquizz ,
We don't close a dispute before we've had a refund.