sale custode new beetle cabriolet, arrived broken
Summary: nollan2006 expresses frustration after an eBay sale where a product, well packaged, arrived broken to the buyer in Germany. They suspect the buyer of having swapped the item with an old broken one to get a refund. Despite several calls to eBay, the guidance was inconsistent, and the situation was not resolved in the seller’s favor. Several participants advise nollan2006 to stop selling on eBay and mention that the platform often favors buyers in this kind of dispute.
Hello, I’ve been on eBay for more than 22 years, and I’ve rarely had problems when I sell something, but lately it feels like they’re piling up on this site... and that it’s an open door to "scams" or unscrupulous people...
I sold a quarter window for a New Beetle Cabriolet (hard to find) to a German guy (who apparently has plenty of VW parts at home..) except it arrived broken (the packaging was done properly with plenty of bubble wrap and a box inside the box + polystyrene to prevent rubbing etc., I’m used to packing things well..)
The buyer therefore opened a dispute on eBay to get reimbursed, with photos to back it up, damaged box and glass in pieces...
But he didn’t report anything to the carrier and didn’t open the parcel in front of them, so he could also very well have put his old broken window in there, damaged the parcel himself and therefore be trying to get a refund...
For now I have the 430 E blocked, and I was called back by eBay at my request, who tell me that the buyer seems "reliable" to them (30 ratings and probably not overusing the "system"..) but it only takes once to scam 430 E, right..
The operator also told me that they wouldn’t ask for the product to be returned since it was broken and that it wasn’t worth it... then at 5:56 PM it cut off, I think they hung up on me since their service closes at 6 PM grrrrr unbelievable!!
I wanted your opinions on what to do because it seems absurd to me: I send an item in good condition (and can prove it) and in the end it supposedly arrived broken and I lose 430E... and since I already find eBay fees very expensive, I’m really asking myself whether to close my eBay account or just not sell anything there anymore...
Thanks in advance for your info
nollan2006
OPhi, so after being invited by a 1st call and then a 2nd call (since they never say the same thing !!) by eBay support to send a return label to the buyer via the eBay platform, which couldn’t be done since it was an international parcel (Germany/France), I had to ask to be called back a 2nd time, and there I was told to forget the first 2..^^ and to send via PayPal to the buyer the amount of the return shipping costs, which could be reimbursed to me by PayPal eventually.
But I hadn’t really understood why this procedure??? so I asked the eBay advisor the question, and she told me that by getting the parcel back I could ask for a refund for non-compliance of the returned item!!
So I resigned myself to this solution, because more than €400 is at stake...
Today I receive the parcel from Germany, parcel as expected with the broken cabriolet roof panel...so I ask to be called back by eBay, 1st call, after 5/6 minutes he hangs up on me !!!
2nd call, I’m told that I won’t be able to get a refund because there’s no seller guarantee !!!!
BUT WHAT KIND OF **bleep** CUSTOMER SERVICE seriously....not one says the same thing over 6 calls...
Aside from my intention to ROYALLY TRASH EBAY on Facebook, Insta (more than 8000 followers on my account) forums and to invite people to NOT SELL ANYTHING on the site because any buyer can NOT REPORT ANYTHING OR OPEN THE PARCEL in front of the carrier and enjoy a refund for their “old” broken item and take the **bleep** in the parcel and photograph it INSTEAD OF the NEW one received unbroken....and “**bleep**” the seller....
There you go, how do you keep your cool in front of this M... platform that was rushed together ????
So, no way to open a claim on eBay for my returned parcel that doesn’t match what I sent and that I can fully prove with photos, since I always take photos of what I send...??
Thanks in advance for your experience...
Anonymous User
Hello,
Unfortunately for you, eBay still favors buyers, and as you were told on the phone, there is no seller protection.
Taking photos is pointless since eBay doesn't take them into account.
Since they introduced their new "selling experience," it's not good to sell here.
Sad to say, but you should try selling somewhere else.
francois-o
Hello,
I'm sorry to read that you're having a bad experience after a sale on eBay.
I'm not surprised to read that he didn't open the parcel in front of the carrier, they're always in a rush. It's rare for parcels to be opened in front of the carrier. (Usually you get home to open the parcel). That said, I agree with you, given the item ordered and a damaged box it would have been wise to do so.
Unfortunately it's always difficult to establish the buyer's good faith in this kind of situation. However, it is also very possible that he received the broken window and in that case it is legitimate to open a dispute.
In this situation, the buyer asks the seller for a refund. The seller asks the carrier for a refund.
(The carrier of parcels is legally responsible for loss and damage caused to the parcel during transport.)
Without access to the dispute and the order details, I can only make assumptions. You need to contact customer service.
Or else you can contact me directly via our social networks => Facebook / Instagram / Twitter
Because this is personal information and we won't be able to resolve this dispute from this discussion channel.
Kind regards
François
nollan2006
OPhello, thanks for your "constructive" reply, how can I contact you personally please?
koalagris
Hello @nollan2006
Click on François's username (in blue at the top of his post) and you will then see the mention "send a message" (it will be a private message where you can include personal information).
best regards
max2661953
Hello, @nollan2006 ,
You're the umpteenth victim of EB's famous free exchange system, the new and working one in exchange for the old and broken.
nollan2006
OPso what do you advise me to do apart from NOT SELLING ANYTHING ON EBAY ANYMORE?? because 430E down the drain there...
I was thinking of contacting the CNIL for legal action...
Anonymous User
Why contact the CNIL?
I don't see the connection.
nollan2006
OPThe CNIL can handle complaints about disputes on the internet (I have already contacted them several years ago.. for issues with a phone operator), and given that EBAY is becoming abusive as I’ve been able to read on certain forums, what’s more I had taken out insurance for the parcel via Laposte but since the buyer did not open the parcel in front of the carrier, I can’t do anything to get a refund but well the buyer knew very well he would not open it...since he put his broken window in the parcel instead of mine...and gets a nice refund...
francexpressdeal
@nollan2006
you may have already dealt with the CNIL in the past, but for the problem you have, they won’t step in. They absolutely do not handle disputes related to internet transactions, only any issues related to the processing of personal data.
Anonymous User
I understand better, but here the case is different and unfortunately I don't think the CNIL will intervene in this case.
Good luck with your efforts.