The buyer made a mistake in their assessment
Summary: koursk explains that he sold an item on eBay for €5 but received a neutral rating despite a positive comment from the customer, who seems not to understand the system. koalagris advises that it is often impossible to change a rating once the 30-day period has passed. Although this neutral rating does not significantly affect the profile, koursk says he is frustrated by eBay’s high commission fees, namely 20%. Several participants discuss the rating procedures and how they influence sales on the platform. noctisauxroses responds critically, suggesting that koursk’s concerns are unfounded. Other participants point out that neutral ratings do not have a major impact on sellers’ reputation.
Hello
I sold an item for €5 including shipping, the customer is satisfied but clearly he doesn’t understand the ebay system, so he left a neutral rating accompanied by a positive comment. I wrote to him but since he doesn’t understand the system he simply sent me a message confirming his satisfaction, without changing the rating. ebay took €1, which is still 20%, I wrote to ebay but of course got no reply. It’s really disappointing to see that ebay takes a big commission on a tiny sale, then lets customers fill out their ratings however they want.
noctisauxroses
The Ebay commission is only 10%, not 20%. Plus the fixed fee. And if you sell items for €1 plus shipping on Ebay, unless you’re doing it in quantities like 1000 per day, it means you’re the one who hasn’t understood anything about the site.
As for feedback, I stopped worrying about it a long time ago; it’s been years since any buyer has left one, consumer society, I buy and move on to something else before I’ve even received the previous item. As a result, I’ve barely got 150 feedback ratings on this account after more than 400 items sold.
Feedback on Ebay has had no importance for years...
aimeemich
hello - A neutral review has no impact on your profile. It's just unpleasant. You always have the option of explaining why by responding to the review.
koursk
OPHello, of course I wrote to the customer right away (and then to eBay). It’s only on this forum that I’m complaining late. It’s not dramatic, of course, but it’s annoying to see eBay take 20% without providing even minimal after-sales service
koalagris
ok but had you, yes or no, sent him an official request to change the feedback? (a message isn't enough) :
https://www.ebay.fr/help/selling/leaving-feedback-buyers/contester-des-valuations-reues?id=4102&st=3&pos=2&query=Contester%20des%20%C3%A9valuations%20re%C3%A7ues&intent=modifier%20%C3%A9valuation&lucenceai=lucenceai&docId=HELP1104
otherwise he couldn't do it...
eBay isn't going to make that decision in the buyer's place.
he can probably still add an additional comment to his feedback, it's up to you to ask him to do so (if this rating is really bothering you) :
https://www.ebay.fr/help/buying/leaving-feedback-sellers/afficher-et-modifier-des-valuations-laisses-aux-vendeurs?id=4031&st=3&pos=1&query=Afficher%20et%20modifier%20des%20%C3%A9valuations%20laiss%C3%A9es%20aux%20vendeurs&intent=modifier%20%C3%A9valuation&lucenceai=lucenceai&docId=HELP1054#section1
noctisauxroses
Alright, another nitpicker complained 6 months later because he realizes that by selling an item for €2 + €3 shipping fees, with the commission, he's losing money. He should've done the math আগে...
koursk
OPI just wanted to reply to your message but when I tried to do it eBay marked it as an "approved solution"! oh well, never mind
yes of course I followed the entire official procedure right away but the customer doesn't understand anything and eBay couldn't care less
I'm not replying to "noctisauxroses" whose answers are completely off topic and have nothing to do with my case
*miss-tigri*
Hello @koursk
You only have 30 days to request a review change, so it’s clearly too late.
It’s not a big deal because a neutral review doesn’t affect your profile 😉
koursk
OPit's the 3rd time I'm saying that I reacted immediately and that it's only on this forum that I react late
but indeed not dramatic
*miss-tigri*
Sorry, I hadn’t reread this post in full..
If I had done that, I would have read that @koalagris ( hello 😉) had given you a complete reply on September 30, so it was therefore unnecessary for me to chime in today..
Have a nice Sunday ..
koalagris
🤗 @*miss-tigri*
have a nice Sunday too 🙂
noctisauxroses
Well listen, if you think my response doesn’t answer your request, start by rereading your request 😉 Apart from the fact that you received a poor rating that you consider unjustified, and you got responses on that subject, in your post you were complaining about the fees charged by Ebay, and whether you like it or not I replied to you on the subject 😉
noctisauxroses
It was you who approved the solution; at some point you necessarily clicked to decide that the proposed solution worked for you, under no circumstances can a forum "staff member" do it in your place. !!! It's awful, this bad faith.
In 20 years of selling on Ebay I've never come across this kind of problem (which you're unable to describe)
Should we infer from this that Koursk (k141-koursk, submarine sunk by Russia which left its men to die on board so that the world would know nothing about it, a run-of-the-mill assassination) is a Russian fake and that Ebay is unable to protect us from it just as we are being overrun everywhere ???
koalagris
Hello @koursk
A buyer doesn't have the ability to edit a feedback left if the seller doesn't send them a request to that effect within 30 days of the feedback being posted, and your neutral rating has long since gone past that deadline = why are you only worrying about it now?
(and when it comes to a neutral, which has no impact on the %, it's risky to make that request, for fear of getting a negative instead).
The buyer can leave an additional comment, and the seller can (as you did) leave a response to the feedback.
Very honestly, everyone can see it's a mistake, which in the end does you no harm whatsoever....
best regards